Articles

How Much is a Lakh?

Coaching early and at scale to ensure the right entries get the right love

July 28, 20267 min readBen Condit
How Much is a Lakh?

NO DO NOT ENTER –

...Results are impossible to judge if using "lakhs." Nobody outside of India knows what the heck that is.

That line sits inside a Word document, next to a finished awards entry for Mountain Dew. No client saw it. No jury saw it. It came from the review that ran before either did.

In 2016, the region asked a small awards council, senior strategists pulled from across the markets, to review a subset of entries before the region paid to develop and submit them to the 2017 Festival of Media Asia Pacific Awards. I had a seat on that council. One batch of nine entries came through from five other markets: Hong Kong, India, Indonesia, Taiwan, Vietnam. The council's sign-off sat between a developing the entry into a case film and paid entry submissions.

Nine entries, one verdict scale, no in-between mood: six got a flat "NO, do not enter" (two of those six were the same Mountain Dew case, entered into two different categories with the same underlying weaknesses). One got a conditional no, with a note that a full rewrite might work at a different show. One got a qualified yes, heavily line-edited, flagged for a rewrite of the objective section before it went anywhere. Only one got a clean "YES, enter."

The four critical questions

Four questions repeat across the notes, entry after entry.

1) Whether someone outside the market can understand the result without translation. A lakh means nothing to a juror in London. A raw view count without a base rate means just as little to anyone.

2) Whether the strategy section connects to the objective and the execution, or reads like three sections written separately and stapled together. One entry got flagged for reading "like a very lazy retrofit," where the strategy summary had no bearing on what actually got executed.

3) Whether the work is genuinely new, or effective media planning already covered by the category brief. Effective and award-worthy are not the same test. Several notes draw that line explicitly: sound strategy, real sales lift, still no shot with a jury, because nothing about the approach was novel.

4) Whether the budget is disclosed at all. One entry got sent back for leaving it out entirely. You'd be surprised how often that happened.

This wasn't grading. It was coaching.

The notes weren't verdicts dropped from a height. Reading past the header line, most of them are edits: paragraphs rewritten in place, sections told to move, sentences flagged for the exact reason they didn't work.

The Ramadhan entry got a rewritten objectives paragraph, a note to move a stray insight out of the strategy section and into the insight section where it belonged, and a direct question about a results claim nobody had backed with data: "Where is supporting data for only being interested in tips and tricks? Why do you share this statement if the execution had nothing to do with tips and tricks?"

The Tropicana entry got called out for arguing three different messages inside one strategy section, quoted back to it verbatim, because a jury can't reward a campaign entry that hasn't decided what it is.

The Pepsi entry that earned the clean pass still got a reworded title, a paragraph rewritten to reorder the argument, and one flat rule stated once: never name the agency inside an entry, or it gets disqualified before a judge reads a word.

None of that is a score. It's a fix list, ranked by what would move the entry furthest, written by people who'd seen enough winning and losing entries to know which fix mattered first.

The complication

Cross-checked against the FOMA 2017 published shortlist, none of the nine entries made it. Not one. That includes the entry that got the clean "YES, enter": a Pepsi campaign in Vietnam built around a branded karaoke app tied to Vietnam Idol.

Good triage killed six weak entries before they cost real money.

It didn't turn the three survivors into winners.

What this actually cost, every cycle

The council convened every award cycle, and cycles land several times a year. By a fair estimate, that ran at minimum three times a year, and some sittings covered far more than nine cases once other markets were added in. Nine was a small session.

Run it across the year at that cadence and the number stops being trivial. At £260 GBP per entry, repeated across dozens of cases a year, every weak submission that gets waved through is real money walking out the door before a jury ever opens the file. It's also resource that could have invested in entries with a better chance of conversion. More than entry fees are the professionally produced two-minute videos.

None of that counts the time cost, and there's no spare version of that time at any size of agency. Every hour spent on that council came out of client work, not out of some idle margin sitting around waiting to be useful. Worth doing. Still a real trade, every single sitting.

Training the region, not just the entry

Coaching one entry teaches one team, for one cycle. Asking the same four questions across five markets, cycle after cycle, teaches the region.

By a few rounds in, the same mistakes stopped showing up as often. Fewer entries came back missing a budget line. Fewer came back with a results section nobody outside the market could parse. Markets absorbed the fix from the last cycle before the next one arrived, because the same reviewer kept asking the same questions.

That's infrastructure a network can afford to run and a lone agency usually can't: a standing feedback loop across markets that builds craft over years, not just clears this quarter's entries.

Where the gap actually sits

Most agencies don't have that infrastructure, and most can't build it. A decade of jury pattern-recognition simply doesn't grow as fast inside a 20-person shop running one award cycle a year on a fixed entry budget, and there's no regional council to borrow a seat on. Even where the judgment exists on paper, in a founder or a single senior hire, pulling that person off client work for the hours a proper review takes is a real cost, and a 20-person shop feels it far more than a network with multiple markets' worth of senior people to spread the same trade across.

That's the actual gap. Access to the years of repetition that build the rubric in someone's head, at the cost outlined above, paid over and over by whoever has the years to spare.

Shortlist was built to close that gap without asking every agency to grow their own decade, or borrow a council seat they don't have. Coach Mode does what these notes actually did: not a pass or fail, but a prioritized fix list ranked by which change moves an entry furthest, the same call an experienced reviewer makes by hand, minus the hours pulled off client work to make it.

It's a shortcut to the discipline, not a replacement for the years that built it. And because that coaching applies to every entry, not just one, it does the second thing a lone agency can't do on its own: train the eye over time, the way five markets needed fewer corrections after a few rounds of the same questions asked back at them.

Where it doesn't

Worth stating plainly, because the temptation is to round this up into a cleaner story than it is.

Killing six of nine entries saved somewhere between £1,284 and £1,560 GBP in entry fees alone, before counting the video budget that never got spent chasing a shortlist that was never coming.

It did not turn the Pepsi karaoke app into a shortlisted entry.

Judgment reduces waste. It doesn't guarantee a trophy.

Anyone selling the second claim is selling something else.

Awards intelligence, built by someone who ran one

Your final edit, brought forward as fast as possible.

30+ shows. Unlimited entries. The judgment stays yours.

Start free trial