Articles

The Trophy Matters More Than You're Supposed to Say

Once an agency gets the taste of winning, it wants to win again

June 4, 20264 min readBen Condit
The Trophy Matters More Than You're Supposed to Say

There is a phone call I still think about.

Mindshare China's first serious awards season in 2014. We put together entries for MMA China without entirely knowing what we were doing. To manage budgets we were producing case study videos out of Bali. Surfers with no concept of deadlines. We nearly lost our minds getting the entries in.

Then Amrita called. She'd thought we'd won four medals. Not golds, but medals. We thought that was cool enough.

Then she said: she thought we might have won MMA Agency of the Year.

We hadn't remotely considered that possibility.

Turns out she was right.

Campaign China Agency of the Year Gold the same year. And the year after that. When we didn't take gold in 2016, the whole agency felt it. We lost a key pitch that year too. Both stung. We came back harder in 2017.

For more than a decade, in every show we entered, Mindshare China was typically gold. At worst silver. When silver came, it felt like failure. That chip drove us forward.

That's not a healthy relationship with awards, you might say. Perhaps. But it's an honest one. The expectation had shifted. We weren't just another agency anymore. We were the agency other agencies measured themselves against. Everyone inside the building knew it. Everyone around us felt it. We expected ourselves to operate accordingly.

More than a decade of momentum in a market where two or three years is the norm.

The industry talks about awards the way it talks about a lot of things it privately cares about deeply: with studied indifference. The politically correct position is that trophies are vanity metrics. That clients don't care. That the real work is the work.

But here's what actually happens inside an agency that wins.

Pride in the work keeps the best people in the building. The best people produce work worth entering. Work worth entering, entered properly, wins. Winning raises the standard. The standard attracts better people and better clients. The cycle feeds itself.

At a certain point, the conversation stops being cultural and starts becoming capital allocation. The retention numbers improve. The new business conversion rate improves. The agency that has been building momentum year after year becomes the one clients want to be associated with. Not because of the trophy shelf. Because of what the trophy shelf signals about the people inside.

The studied indifference is a myth the losing agencies tell themselves. The winning agencies know better. They just don't advertise it.

Awards weren't the only reason Mindshare China held its position for more than a decade. Strong leadership. A CEO who was a force on new business. A team that had been building for years before the trophies started arriving.

But the winning was part of the culture. And the culture became the thing that was nearly unstoppable.

The two are not separate. The culture that produces awards produces everything else too. The rigour, the pride, the refusal to accept silver when gold is the standard. Those aren't award season qualities. They're the qualities that show up in the room with the client, in the brief, in the work itself.

You can't manufacture that from the outside. But you can build the conditions for it. And it starts with giving the work its moment.

The reality back then was we simply never had enough hours to give every piece of work the attention it deserved.

The strategy team exceeded every expectation. At the expense of their evenings. Just like the client teams who built the work being showcased. The cycle that drove us forward also consumed the people powering it. That's the part nobody talks about when they talk about building a winning culture.

Shortlist was built so that doesn't have to be the trade-off.

The work still has to be there. The judgment still has to be there. But the process: the directions, the drafts, the evaluation, the press materials. That part doesn't have to cost your best people their nights anymore.

Every agency that should be in this cycle deserves the chance to find out if they are.

Shortlist is an awards intelligence system for agencies. gotshortlisted.com

Awards intelligence, built by someone who ran one

Your final edit, brought forward as fast as possible.

30+ shows. Unlimited entries. The judgment stays yours.

Start free trial